Welcome to the Gem City Cookie Company

About Us


Who - Stephanie Pierron, Owner and Artist

Left outside a tree as a newborn and subsequently raised by elves, Stephanie honed her craft while studying abroad in Paris at both the Louvre and Le Cordon Bleu.  Forced to flee France due to accusations of witchcraft based on her uncanny cookie artistry, Stephanie found refuge and eventual acceptance in the Gem City.  

Fluent in 12 languages, including both Braille and Morse Code, Stephanie enjoys spending time with her children and adoring husband, amateur cartography, and drag-racing her '32 Studebaker Dictator Coupe around Dayton in her free time.


What - Awesome and Unique Cookies, That's What

Creating edible art for individuals, teams, groups, or corporate functions, our goal is to make your day special by designing custom cookies down to your smallest specification.

Cookies can be boxed together, individually packaged, bagged, or wrapped.  Pick-up and delivery (Dayton-area only) is available, or shipping to Ohio addresses via USPS (additional fee).


Why - As If You Need To Ask...

There is never a wrong time for cookies!  From birthday parties and bridal showers to successful hernia surgeries, uncontested divorces, criminal acquittals and all points in between, celebrating with a delicious, hand-crafted cookie is guaranteed to make your event all the more memorable.

We will proudly create a custom cookie for any occasion.  If you can think it or celebrate it, we've got you covered.

Real Testimonials

Melissa H. Has to Say...


"Amazingly delicious!  Tasty works of art are found here when you choose Gem City Cookie Company. Thank you, Stephanie!"

Megan D. Has to Say...


"The BEST! We just loved these!"

"Gorgeous, delicious, and such a perfect complement to our Wizard of Oz birthday party! What a hit! Stephanie is truly talented."

Jennifer B. Has to Say....


"The cookies that I bought for Valentine's Day were wonderful. I hate to use a cliche, but they really do taste as good as they look. Thank you!"

Kate S. Has to Say...


"We loved these cookies! They were so delicious and exactly what I wanted!  Thank you, thank you!"

Jamie L. Has to Say...


"Everyone raved about the design as well as the taste! Easy to work with and puts out a great product! I highly recommend!"

Kate H. Has to Say...


"I could not be happier with my Boss’s Day cookies! Sloths are my favorite! Beautiful!!! And delicious!"


Sign up so we can share special cookies, deals, and other assorted whatnot with you. Your info is private and will not be shared with the KGB.

Contact Us

Questions and Comments

Ordering Info

Especially large and complex cookies may require extra time and love.  The sooner you order, the better!  Please order within five days (or more) of your event.  We will try to accommodate orders falling within five days, but can make no guarantees!

Gem City Cookie Company

Vandalia, Ohio, United States

(937) 823-2098


Online/Email - 24/7

Phone/Text - 9:30a to 5:30p, please

Payment Info

You don't think we'd do this for free, right?

Pay with PayPal or a debit/credit card